From the company:
What it is:
A contouring eye pencil for a big, beautiful look that lasts up to 12 hours.
What it does:
Enhance and enliven your eyes with the bold, long-wearing color of these eye pencils. The silky formula is resistant to water, heat, and humidity, ensuring up to 12 hours of smudge-less wear.
What it is formulated WITHOUT:
I was looking for an olive green eyeliner when Fall started. I generally don't wear a lot of colored eyeliner, but olive green is a very wearable shade and brings out my brown eyes.
Rooftop party has a shimmery sheen, no chunky sparkle detected. It's very pigmented on the first pass, and stayed on my waterline for 10 hours. I agree this is definitely waterproof, but isn't a hassle to remove like most eyeliners that won't budge even with makeup remover.
Rate : A
Available at Sephora : $9